What makes a record useful?
A worker should not have to begin a qualification history from scratch every time an employer changes. A receiving organization also needs to know who issued each record, what it covers and whether it is current. A useful portable record connects those needs without turning a person’s entire work history into an open database.
This brief proposes how ATG could test that design. It concerns the evidence attached to a worker’s achievement and the rights around its use. It does not report a deployed registry, an employer agreement or completed testing. The companion fatality brief addresses the separate question of responsibility across a project’s contracting chain.
Start with the issuer and preserve the original
Some verification infrastructure already exists. NWSA has moved to digital credentials with an issuer verification route. FOA provides official online credential records with validity information. A future ATG record should reference those sources and preserve their scope rather than imply that a copied badge replaces the issuer’s authority. (NWSA digital credentials; FOA online credentials)
An assessment outcome, an experience record and permission to perform a specific assignment should remain distinguishable. A verified issuer record may support a decision; the responsible organization must still determine what evidence that decision needs. A screenshot without its source, scope or date can conceal more than it proves.
Separate the portable view from protected files
Registered apprenticeship standards illustrate why different records are needed. 29 CFR 29.5 calls for a work-process outline and periodic evaluation of job performance and related instruction, with appropriate progress records. That supports keeping experience and assessment evidence intelligible over time. It does not imply that ATG is registered. (29 CFR 29.5)
Under 29 CFR 30.12, covered sponsors must retain specified selection and program records, generally for five years, and keep medical information separately and confidentially subject to stated exceptions. These scoped duties caution against either publishing a complete file or promising unrestricted deletion. A real system needs a records policy matched to its actual legal obligations. (29 CFR 30.12)
The proposed portable view would show the minimum evidence required for an agreed purpose. Detailed personnel, medical, accommodation and complaint records would stay in separately controlled systems. The design should provide a correction route without exposing those records to every organization checking a qualification.
The minimum useful record
This is a proposed field set for testing, not an adopted ATG schema. Each field must have a defined purpose, custodian and access rule before real worker information is collected.
- Person match
- A protected holder identifier and a proportionate matching method. A name alone is insufficient; government ID numbers should not become public lookup keys.
- Claim and scope
- The exact achievement, assessment or experience claimed, issuer and applicable standard/version. Distinguish examined knowledge, observed skill and recorded hours.
- Dates and status
- Issue and assessment dates, validity conditions where applicable, and source of any expiry, suspension or correction. Preserve status as of the check.
- Verification trail
- Authoritative source, verification method and time, result and unresolved limits. Record an unavailable issuer as unresolved rather than silently valid or invalid.
- Evidence and review
- A controlled reference to supporting evidence, its custodian, and the correction/appeal route. Do not embed the whole personnel file in the portable record.
- Use and change history
- Who received which fields for what authorized purpose, and how corrections are communicated. Preserve prior versions under a defined retention policy.
A decision record should then identify which evidence a receiving organization used, when it used it and what limits it applied. Keeping that decision separate from the underlying credential allows an error in one to be corrected without rewriting the other.
Technology cannot decide whom to trust
The W3C Verifiable Credentials model describes tamper-evident claims exchanged among issuers, holders and verifiers. Its definition explicitly separates technical verification from the truth of a claim. The verifier still decides whether to trust an issuer. Its privacy guidance calls for limiting requested information and warns that identifiers and verification activity can correlate a person across contexts. (W3C credentials model)
ATG could test these principles with ordinary protected records before choosing a technical format. No blockchain, wallet product or vendor integration is prescribed here. Any later implementation would need its own security and privacy testing.
Make correction part of the design
ATG’s public Member Conduct and Protections guide distinguishes earned standing from current safety qualifications. It also describes accurate records, notice, an opportunity to respond and review separate from the original determination. The Public Charter adds independent evaluation and appeal commitments. These principles are a reason to test correction mechanisms early, before records affect real opportunities. (ATG conduct and protections; ATG Public Charter)
The public guide still calls for detailed process alignment before a signing edition. ATG remains a developing institution with a proposed, not-yet-registered apprenticeship and closed enrollment. This brief should not be read as an active certification, audit or worker-placement service.
Test with fictional records first
A first test can use clearly labeled synthetic cases. No real worker files, employer outreach or new system access is authorized or initiated by this proposal. A later consent-based pilot would need a written protocol, participating organizations, accountable data custodians and review of legal and privacy requirements.
- Try mistaken identity: two fictional people with similar names. Test whether the reviewer can detect the mismatch without exposing unnecessary identifiers.
- Try changing status: a valid record that later expires, a corrected assessment and an unavailable issuer. Check whether the history and uncertainty remain visible, rather than becoming a single misleading green status.
- Try a disputed entry: provide a correction request and contradictory evidence. Track who can amend the record, who reviews the dispute and how the holder sees the outcome. A prototype must not make real adverse decisions.
- Try limited disclosure: ask for one qualification and inspect everything actually returned. Look for unrelated personal information, hidden file metadata and access links that expose more than the intended record.
- Measure retrieval time, successful person matching, reconstructable verification decisions, correction turnaround in the test and unintended disclosures. Report the number and design of test cases; synthetic success is not a measured field benefit.
The useful outcome
The first deliverable should be an evidence trail that another reviewer can follow and a privacy boundary that a worker can understand. A portable record earns its usefulness when achievements remain attributable, current limits remain visible and mistakes can be challenged. ATG should demonstrate those properties before asking anyone to rely on the record for hiring, advancement or assignment decisions.
Sources and scope
Sources checked November 3, 2026. Issuer policies describe their own programs. ATG guides describe proposed institutional commitments, not independent proof of performance or an operating intake.
NWSA digital certification announcement May 22 2025. Existing issuer verification infrastructure. It is not evidence of an ATG integration or a worker’s individual current status. Open source ↗
FOA online credentials. Official online credential records and QR access. Access to a credential record is distinct from access to a personnel file. Open source ↗
29 CFR 29.5 Standards of apprenticeship. Paragraphs (b)(3) and (b)(6) address work processes, supervised experience and progress evaluation/records. Applies to registration standards; it does not establish ATG registration. Open source ↗
29 CFR 30.12 Recordkeeping. Sponsor records, retention and confidential medical information. The scope is apprenticeship equal opportunity obligations, not every worker record everywhere. Open source ↗
W3C Verifiable Credentials Data Model version 2. Recommendation May 15, 2025; terminology, trust model and privacy considerations. A technical model, not proof of claim truth or an ATG implementation. Open source ↗
ATG Member Conduct and Protections reading guide. Public summary of accurate-record, earned-standing and fair-review commitments. Detailed provisions still require alignment before a signing edition. Open source ↗
ATG Public Charter reading guide. Independent evaluation and separate appeal are stated design commitments, not evidence of an operational adjudication service. Open source ↗